Answering All Podcast Controversies: Full Info Here!
Reply All’s reputation was at an all-time high in the summer of 2013. In a recent episode of a long-running internet-themed podcast, a man was featured who had a 90s pop song stuck in his head that no one else on the planet could remember. An investigation by the show’s hosts, PJ Vogt and Alex Goldman, went to great lengths and enlisted the help of some of the hottest names in music to help out. I couldn’t guess what was going to happen next because the plot was so well paced and unpredictable. Some podcast fans consider The Case of the Missing Hit the best of all time.
Soon, Reply All was making headlines for all the wrong reasons. Starting in 2021, a spin-off miniseries titled The Test Kitchen will explore the allegedly toxic and racist work environment of food magazine Bon Appétit. The miniseries will be available on Netflix. As a result, a former employee of Gimlet Media, the company that produces Reply All, accused the team behind The Test Kitchen of promoting a similar atmosphere at Gimlet.
As a result, Vogt and Sruthi Pinnamaneni, a Reply All producer and host of The Test Kitchen have been singled out and accused of actively opposing diversification and unionization efforts within the company. The test kitchen was axed and work on Reply All was put on hold while the two were given unpaid leave from Gimlet.
Until recently. After a brief and annoying explainer in April, the podcast is making a tentative return this week. When Emmanuel Dzotsi took over as the show’s third presenter in October 2020, the episode described the downfall of the podcast and posed existential questions about its future. Goldman will now be the show’s permanent co-host. She spoke in an uneasy and uncertain tone. Dzotsi said of the show’s relaunch, “We don’t know if it’s going to work.” These sentiments are shared by many others.
However, Reply All isn’t the only podcast trying to restore its reputation following a media storm. A popular podcast brand is a hot commodity these days, so Spotify-owned Gimlet was unlikely to just hand over the show. The success of Reply All rests on a foundation of value that must be preserved. Is it because of her unwavering dedication to online ephemera? A storytelling that stands out? Maybe it’s because of the series’ underlying theme, true long-term friendship?
Read also : A strange controversy surrounds the Spy X family!
It will be the last for Gimlet, and he hopes it won’t be the last. When Vogt and Goldman started the podcast in 2014, they had already been friends for some time (in the April episode, Goldman sadly revealed that he had never had a job in the industry that didn’t). did not involve his former co-host). There’s no denying that part of Reply All’s appeal was their host-to-host rapport, which gave their reporting a refreshing personal touch.
The tone of a podcast can quickly turn sour if this dynamic is upset. poppy hill, a former co-host of Gossipmongers with David Earl and Joe Wilkinson, claimed on Twitter in September that she had been fired from her job as co-host. Hillstead was fired by two men she considered friends after three series because she was told she “lacks the necessary experience”.
Poppy Hillstead entered the chat, Hillstead’s new podcast, was nominated for Best Comedy Podcast at the British Podcast Awards earlier this month. The Gossipmongers iTunes page was flooded with reviews bemoaning Hillstead’s abrupt departure, despite Wilkinson and Earl failing to respond to the controversy.
Vogt’s departure from Reply All may have a similar effect on the show’s popularity. In the wake of the allegations against him, the show’s nerdy but charming air has been tarnished. It’s also possible that Goldman and Dzotsi are the driving forces behind the podcast and it will thrive under their leadership. For example, the myth-busting podcast You’re Wrong About had hosts meet in person five months after recording the show remotely. Dzotsi’s previous work on the podcast suggests that he and Goldman are already closer than that – but the on-air chemistry Reply All was built on is by no means inevitable.
One of the issues raised by the Test Kitchen saga is the unfiltered privacy that many traded podcasts are provided by huge corporations (Spotify paid $230 million for Gimlet in 2019). Making a big deal out of the money and greed of the companies involved can alienate viewers. It’s unfortunate that the friendship between Sofia Franklyn and Alexandra Cooper, hosts of the sex and lifestyle podcast “Call Her Daddy”, has come to an end, along with the public airing of their contract dispute. Call Her Daddy, a podcast acquired by Barstool Sports in 2018, was the fifth most popular podcast on Spotify in 2020 – until it ended abruptly that spring, without explanation.
Barstool CEO David Portnoy called the women “unprofessional, disloyal and greedy” after they turned down $500,000 in salary and bonuses, leading to their demise. Over time, Cooper and Franklyn came to an agreement and Franklyn left the show, with Cooper continuing to host Call Her Daddy on her own and her own podcast taking her place.
Social media users expressed their displeasure at the potential payoff for the “everyday” hosts, while former fans expressed their displeasure with the pair’s individual ventures in reviews online. Call Her Daddy is still a popular podcast, proving the value of an established brand, despite the fact that neither was able to replicate the success of their joint venture.
Many Gimlet employees felt undervalued and exploited when calculating Reply All, even though it focused on the behavior of a few individuals. Much will depend on the quality of Goldman and Dzotsi’s version to determine whether or not the negative connotations associated with Reply All will be overlooked by listeners.
Read also : Dana Isaly Controversy: What is your opinion on The Dana Islay and Willow Winters Craze?
In podcasting, a well-crafted story is a rare commodity. However, they must be able to tell big, untold stories in a believable way. Caliphate, the New York Times’ much-loved podcast on ISIS’s activities in Syria, has been accused of plagiarism and unreliability in recent years, relying heavily on lengthy interview segments with a man who claimed to have been involved in ISIS activities, including murder. The credibility of its claims was questioned and as a result Caliphate withdrew its Peabody Award and The New York Times admitted that some episodes failed to meet its standards for accuracy.
Even though Goldman said Reply All’s investigations are verified externally, the alleged hypocrisy that debunked The Test Kitchen’s story undermined the show in a more subtle way. To get to the bottom of something as sensitive as workplace racism, you need to have a clean record. An expose is doomed if the sleuth is involved in another scandal of the same nature.
Reply ‘All’ became a hit because it had so many of the best qualities in podcasting: warm, relatable hosts with a real connection going on a journey of discovery through scrupulous reporting. How well Goldman and Dzotsi are able to recreate that DIY charm in a world where big podcasts mean business will be essential to its recovery. Is it possible that he is coming back from the edge? If this does not happen, his time may be limited.